Same watch. The extra is for eSIM.

Short answer

Series 12 42 mm GPS + Cellular - LTE, 5G RedCap and eSIM, slightly lighter (31.5 g). Series 12 42 mm GPS - the same for those whose iPhone is always nearby.

Key differences

SpecApple Watch Series 12 42mm GPSApple Watch Series 12 42mm GPS + Cellular
DisplayOLED, 374×446OLED, 374×446
ChipApple S11Apple S11
Memory64 GB64 GB
Battery lifeup to 24 hup to 24 h
ConnectivityBluetooth, Wi-Fi5G RedCap, LTE, eSIM
NavigationGPS, GLONASS, Galileo, QZSS, BeiDou (L1)GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, QZSS, BeiDou (L1)
NFCyesyes
Sensorsheart rate, SpO2, barometer, compass, gyroscope, temperatureheart rate, SpO2, barometer, compass, gyroscope, temperature
Protection50 m / IP6X50 m / IP6X
OSwatchOS 27watchOS 27
CompatibilityiPhone 11 / iPhone SE 2 / iOS 27iPhone 11 / iPhone SE 2 / iOS 27
Dimensions, weight42×37×9.7 mm, 32.2 g42×37×9.7 mm, 31.5 g
Pricecurrent pricescurrent prices

Specs come from the device pages on Smartphone.ua.

What's the same

Apple S11, 64 GB, 374×446 display, up to 24 h, SpO2, NFC, Ceramic Shield 2, 9.7 mm.

Connectivity

Cellular calls and gets messages without a phone. Without an iPhone nearby the GPS version only works over Wi-Fi.

Who it's for

Run without a phone or want to be reachable at the pool - Cellular. Otherwise GPS is plenty.

Verdict: who should buy which

  • Connected without a phone - Series 12 42 mm GPS + Cellular.
  • Saving money - Series 12 42 mm GPS.

FAQ

Is the display the same?
Yes, 374×446.

How heavy are they?
32.2 and 31.5 g.

Which is cheaper?
The GPS version.

Read also