Same watch. The extra is for phone-free music and Wi-Fi.

Short answer

Forerunner 170 Music - tracks on the watch and Wi-Fi. Forerunner 170 - the same for less if you run with your phone.

Key differences

SpecGarmin Forerunner 170Garmin Forerunner 170 Music
Display1.2", AMOLED, 390×3901.2", AMOLED, 390×390
Memory4 GB4 GB
Battery lifeup to 10 daysup to 10 days
ConnectivityBluetooth, ANT+Bluetooth, ANT+, Wi-Fi
NavigationGPS, GLONASS, GalileoGPS, GLONASS, Galileo
NFCyesyes
Sensorsheart rate, barometer, compass, gyroscope, temperatureheart rate, barometer, compass, gyroscope, temperature
Protection5 ATM5 ATM
CompatibilityiPhone, AndroidiPhone, Android
Dimensions, weight42.6×42.6×11.9 mm, 41 g42.6×42.6×11.9 mm, 41 g
Pricecurrent pricescurrent prices

Specs come from the device pages on Smartphone.ua.

What's the same

1.2" AMOLED 390×390, up to 10 days, GPS, NFC, barometer, gyroscope, 5 ATM, 42.6×42.6×11.9 mm and 41 g.

Music

The Music version stores music and connects headphones directly.

Price

The extra is small, so if you run with headphones I'd take the Music.

Verdict: who should buy which

  • Running without a phone - Forerunner 170 Music.
  • Saving money - Forerunner 170.

FAQ

Is battery life the same?
Yes, up to 10 days.

Is there NFC?
Yes, on both.

Which is cheaper?
The Forerunner 170.

Read also