Both have batteries over 7000 mAh and IP64. The Motorola costs a bit more, but is faster and has FHD+.
Short answer
Moto G57 Power - 5G, Snapdragon 6s Gen 4, FHD+ 120 Hz, 8/256 GB, an 8 MP ultrawide. Redmi 17 - 7500 mAh, 45 W, a 6.9" screen and cheaper.
Key differences
| Spec | Motorola Moto G57 Power | Redmi 17 |
|---|---|---|
| Chip | Qualcomm Snapdragon 6s Gen 4 | MediaTek Helio G91-Ultra |
| Display | 6.72", LCD, 1080×2400, 120 Hz | 6.9", LCD, 720×1600, 120 Hz |
| RAM / storage | 8/256 GB | 4/128 GB, 4/256 GB, 6/128 GB, 6/256 GB |
| Rear cameras | 50 MP + 8 MP | 50 MP |
| Front | 8 MP | 8 MP |
| Battery | 7000 mAh | 7500 mAh |
| Charging | 30 W | 45 W |
| Protection | IP64 | IP64 |
| Thickness / weight | 8.6 mm / 210.6 g | 8.8 mm / 232 g |
| Price | current prices | current prices |
Specs come from the device pages on Smartphone.ua.
Chips
Qualcomm Snapdragon 6s Gen 4 and MediaTek Helio G91-Ultra. The Snapdragon 6s Gen 4 is noticeably faster and has 5G.
Screen
FHD+ on the Motorola vs HD+ on the Redmi, both 120 Hz.
Battery
7500 mAh and 45 W on the Redmi vs 7000 mAh and 30 W on the Motorola.
Verdict: who should buy which
- Speed, screen, memory - Moto G57 Power.
- Battery and price - Redmi 17.
FAQ
Are both protected?
Yes, IP64.
Does the Redmi 17 have 5G?
No.
Which is cheaper?
The Redmi 17.