Two of the most popular budget smartphones. The prices are close, but the approaches are radically different.
Short answer
Redmi Note 17 - a 7700 mAh battery, 45 W, a big 6.99" AMOLED, IP65, an IR blaster, versions up to 8/256 GB. Galaxy A17 - lighter and thinner, One UI with long updates and slightly cheaper.
Key differences
| Spec | Galaxy A17 | Redmi Note 17 |
|---|---|---|
| Chip | Helio G99 | Snapdragon 6s 4G Gen 2 |
| Display | 6.7", Super AMOLED FHD+ | 6.99", AMOLED FHD+, 120 Hz, up to 1800 nits |
| RAM / storage | 4 / 128 GB | 4-8 / 128-256 GB |
| Cameras | 50 + 5 + 2 MP | 50 MP |
| Front | 13 MP | 16 MP |
| Battery | 5000 mAh | 7700 mAh |
| Charging | 25 W | 45 W |
| Protection | IP54 | IP65 |
| Thickness / weight | 7.5 mm / 190 g | 8.45 mm / 224 g |
| Price | current prices | current prices |
Battery
7700 mAh is almost half as much again. For a budget phone that often serves as a workhorse or a phone for parents, battery life is the main thing.
Performance
The 6 nm Helio G99 with A76 cores and the Snapdragon 6s 4G Gen 2 with older A73 cores are close in speed. Both handle messengers, social media and YouTube just fine.
Memory
The A17 has 4/128 GB. The Redmi comes in versions up to 8/256 GB. If you plan to use the phone for 3+ years, I'd take 8 GB.
Verdict: who should buy which
- Battery life and big screen - Redmi Note 17.
- Lightness and updates - Galaxy A17.
- More memory - Redmi Note 17.
- Lowest price - Galaxy A17.
FAQ
What battery does the Redmi Note 17 have?
7700 mAh, 45 W.
Is there 5G?
No, both are 4G. The Redmi's 5G version is the Note 17 5G.
Which is lighter?
The Galaxy A17 - 190 g.